As Apple files request for court order, Samsung complains that 'patent
law can be manipulated to give one company a monopoly over rectangles with
rounded corners.'
Apple is hoping to press its advantage against Samsung
Electronics, asking for a court order on a wider U.S. ban on its products and
an additional $707 million in damages after scoring a victory over the Korean
giant last month.
For the additional request, Apple went back to
the same San Jose, Calif., court that ruled last month that Samsung's products
copied several key elements of the iPhone, Reuters
reported. Samsung, for its part, is seeking a new trial, arguing
that there were a number of instructional errors and decisions on evidence that
require additional examination.
Apple scored a big victory when the San Jose
jury ruled that Samsung had infringed on a number of its key patents and awarded
Apple $1.05 billion in damages.
Following the victory, Apple sought
to ban the products mentioned during the
trial. The company is now seeking to extend that ban to any Samsung products
that potentially infringe on its design patents, which could extend to
Samsung's current flagship Galaxy
S3.
The case in San Jose was just one of many
ongoing trials in the world in a litigation battle that has gone on in multiple
courts in multiple countries. Yesterday, a court in Germany ruled that Samsung
didn't violate an Apple patent related to how the finger reacts to touch screens.
The latest legal developments come as Apple
launched the iPhone 5 on Friday, garnering the usual lines and frenzy
for the launch of a new Apple product. Sales estimates for the iPhone 5 on the
first weekend alone have gone as high as 10 million. Apple and Samsung are in a
tight battle for smartphone supremacy, with Samsung in the lead thanks to the
sheer breadth of different phones it makes.
Samsung again warned that if left to stand, the ruling would hurt
U.S. consumers and lead to less choice and higher prices down the line. It
would also embolden Apple to take other competitors to court, the company said
in a statement e-mailed to CNET.
"Indeed, it is unfortunate that patent law can be manipulated
to give one company a monopoly over rectangles with rounded corners, or
technology that is being improved every day by Samsung and other
companies." Samsung said.
Apple has said that it was seeking damages appropriate to Samsung's
willful use of Apple patents in its products, which has caused harm to the
iPhone maker.
Samsung has already said it would
drag the iPhone 5 into
the legal battle, indicating that there is no likely end to the squabble for a
while.
0 comments:
Post a Comment